Universalis, your very own breviary in pixels...

Friday, 4 December 2009

Making Wishes Come True, By Slaking the Goddess's Thirst

Recent events in Switzerland indicate that the West is not as open to diversity as political correctness might require.
Most mainstream commentators in this country, so far as I have read, (which is admittedly not all that far,) have decried the historically neutral nation's (just remembered, John Oliver on the Daily Show last night, speaking with a Swiss ambassador was devastating...,) disdain for freedom of religion.

I wonder what the reaction would be in Switzerland or the USA to this form of religious expression within their borders?
The world's biggest animal sacrifice began in Nepal today with the killing of the first of more than 250,000 animals as part of a Hindu festival in the village of Bariyapur, near the border with India.
The event, which happens every five years, began with the decapitation of thousands of buffalo, killed in honour of Gadhimai, a Hindu goddess of power.

With up to a million worshippers on the roads near the festival grounds, this year's fair seems more popular than ever, despite vocal protests from animals rights groups who have called for it to be banned. "It is the traditional way, " explained 45-year old Manoj Shah, a Nepali driver who has been attending the event since he was six, "If we want anything, and we come here with an offering to the goddess, within five years all our dreams will be fulfilled."...

In the main event, 250 appointed residents with traditional kukri knives began their task of decapitating more than 10,000 buffalo in a dusty enclosure guarded by high walls and armed police.

Frightened calves galloped around in vain as the men, wearing red bandanas and armbands, pursued them and chopped off their heads. Banned from entering the animal pen, hundreds of visitors scrambled up the three-metre walls to catch a glimpse of the carnage.

And I snobbishly look down my nose at NASCAR...

My Husband the Rock Star

Himself, since he was young, has had a snowy beard.
And though he is fair, a very pink-cheeked look, and yes, despite a childhood accident involving a tricycle and 6 porch steps, a nose not completely unlike a cherry, and a perpetual smile.

You see where I'm going with this....

He is as barrel-chested as any opera singer could wish, so even when not carrying extra weight, he has a certain... presence? And clothes, say... red velvet robes or suits?... hang well.

Add to this eyes so blue and bright that the world "twinkle" does not begin to do them justice, and you have a near ideal St Nicholas or Santa Claus.

He was told years ago that if he wanted it, he would have the level of Santa-playing "career" that he could earn enough during December that he would not need to work the rest of the year.
(A nice way to subsidize poorly paid theater gigs.)

Trouble was? ...he didn't much like kids.
In fact, he is slightly scared of small children, couldn't imagine having them climb into his lap all day long.

Well, this fall came at the end of a progression of "facial hair roles," (beginning with 'stash, and progressing through van dyke to his present luxurious thatch,) and there he was walking around in hirsute splendor when a friend of a friend who was desperate for a better than usual Santa for several dates for his prestigious (non-mercantile, that's important,) institution.

Okay, just this once....

Well, this is a man who has heard ovations from crowds of literally thousands, earned rave reviews in serious work, sung and danced his way through 11 o'clock numbers... but he said he has never felt anything like this, the love, the way kids' heads snap around as he passes, the way he is instantly the focus of all eyes when he enters the room, the way, as he walks from his dressing/break room to the "throne" room it's like being a rock star, "a ROCK star, honey! you've never felt anything LIKE it!!!!"

Nor have I, he's right.

He had his "Miracle on 34th Street" moments, a little French girl who didn't care that they could not communicate with words, (his entire vocabulary consists of Emile DeBeque lines, and he just didn't see telling her that he'd serve the coffee himself....)

But the best was at the end of the evening, the toddler with Down's Syndrome who just wanted to hug him, to love him.

So yeah, I think he may be hooked.

He can't shave the thing off the the first half of 2010 because of another role, and I've been suggesting for years that he think about putting together a one man show about the the life, legends, and facts of the Bishop of Myra, something with a real religious underpinning, something with a real Catholic perspective.
http://www.paleks.com/Icons_files/Saint%2520Nicholas.jpg

We shall see. (Can I say, I'm always pleased with, but I absolutely lurrrrve our home life when he's happy with himself, with his performing career?)

My husband the rock star ;o)

Thursday, 3 December 2009

A Day Late and a Dollar Extra?

I was a bit confused by this story
Weekday Word and Communion services in the Diocese of Little Rock were discontinued Nov. 29 to order to comply with a Vatican document.

It has been a common practice in some places for a deacon or trained layperson to lead the Liturgy of the Word and distribute Communion if a priest was not available. On weekdays, the services were often held on the pastor's day off.

Father Shaun Wesley, director of the Office of Divine Worship, said the services can still be held on Sundays or holy days of obligation because receiving the Eucharist on these days are "of utmost importance."

There relevant portion of "Redemptionis Sacramentum" would be this, I believe:

[166.]Likewise, especially if Holy Communion is distributed during [Celebrations carried out in the Absence of a Priest], the diocesan Bishop, to whose exclusive competence this matter pertains, must not easily grant permission for such celebrations to be held on weekdays, especially in places where it was possible or would be possible to have the celebration of Mass on the preceding or the following Sunday. Priests are therefore earnestly requested to celebrate Mass daily for the people in one of the churches entrusted to their care.

Is the chancery in Arkansas just getting around to reading Redemptionis Sacramentum now, five and a half years later?
And I don't know the circumstances in the diocese of Little Rock, perhaps the practice has been abused, but "not easily granted permission" is not the same as a ban.
On the other hand, the attitudes of some lay people quoted or referenced seem to imply a misunderstanding of sacramental theology, and of course, the "They are defying the Spirit of Vatican Two!" cry is raised.
Liturgy of the Hours is rightly suggested as the most appropriate liturgy for a community when a priest is not available for weekday Mass.

Reading the actual diocesan guidelines, we see that "Weekday Word and Communion services in the place of Mass are not permitted within the diocese without the explicit permission of the Bishop or Vicar General."

Soyes, discontinued, but is that actually because the explicit permission has not been granted? or simply not specifically requested? or not requested yet?

"Liturgical Music - Where has it gone?"

This blog post from a Catholic deacon, asks that question, and judging from the fact that the sober-looking guy who who he thinks has the answer to the question and the solution to the implicit problem, is shown seated, calmly, on the bench of an organ, at the beginning of the video, and that the deacon goes on to say that "a sense of the extreme Holiness of the Mass [needs to be brought] back into our churches through Sacred and Truly Liturgical Music," I really, really, really, really want to know what it is.

But my computer, which Robert Fulton and Alexander Bell seem to have made in their spar time does not like the video, (which seems to begin with the Jacques Arcadelt Ave Maria.)

So if anyone else watches it, will ya please TELL me?

Mission...

... is not a verb, (I don't care what the American Heritage Dictionary says.)

I think using such facilitator-speak should earn you a lifetime ban from giving workshops and lectures.
I feel about it like Louis Black feels about boot-cut jeans.
And I'd feel that way even if I liked "On Eagles Wings."

And while I'm missioning my meager readership about that one, I think I'll also vision a world where... well, where VISION isn't a verb.

Okie-doke?

Wednesday, 2 December 2009

No comment, except...

... does anyone really need photoshop anymore?
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgg2LCdt5X0rnrT_zx_JOd1dsR9_pcipYb3Arm36MNK5fCo4YbyNvN5mtComxKNGY7CeTlXw7RwI8Pyfx46aYw_ENfirjUhzRHi09pb_AmqwLiB8afbUTmwJwrz-kpM9pO8huSgKiF4RqI/s1600/nuns+for+choice.jpg

Pay to Pray? Fascinating, If Bizarre, Lobbying Efforts

Christian Scientists and some friends in high places, (Sen John Kerry? talk about strange bed-fellows...) are seeking to have provisions in the health care reform, for those who pray for others' health -- "professionally" -- to receive reimbursement from insurers, and by extension, the government.

I am conflicted about this -- soothing, perhaps meaningless, counseling is already covered, ("... And how does that makes you feel?" intones Mr Psychologist to his patient.)

Is "We are created in God's perfect image" or "God is life," spoken by a Christian Scientist practioner so very different from "They're just feelings, feelings are never 'wrong,'" or "You have to learn to 'own' your anger," from one of today's more respectable shamans?

On the other hand....

Wouldn't that logically mean that Catholic priests should get government reimbursement for the anointing of the sick?

I think this is a bad road to go down.

But it seems we've already set out....
The Internal Revenue Service allows prayer treatments to be itemized on income tax forms as medical expenses. And a few federal insurance programs, such as those for military families, already reimburse for prayer.

Monday, 30 November 2009

Candy and Christmas and Craziness

There are people for whom i wish to get little Xmas gifts and I figure since I'm gonna buy them something anyway, and there' nothing these people need, when making this little gesture why shouldn't i spend the money with people or orgnizations I want to support...

So is it crazy to buy candy from one community of religious women as opposed to another on no basis other than that the website of one talks about Adoration and Benediction while the other talks about Centering Prayer?

Yeah, probably.

Where to draw the line on funeral texts?

Funeral chaos this week, one in the evening, of all things, (necessitating several hours of rearranging schedules for rehearsals for another gig because the rectory gave me a time, assured me it was written in stone when I explained I had a conflict I would have to resolve; and then called back with no qualms whatever to say the stone had been erased, and THAT, Father, is why you pay the bench fee, because your underpaid MD has made a commitment to put the parish's needs first, and you make it deuced difficult for her to supplement her income in any meaningful way when you pull stuff like that... the trouble is, of course, that it is not he, nor is it the parish that I would leave in the lurch were I to put my foot down, it is a family in mourning.)

And that funeral's the least of my concerns; an obviously protestant-except-for-words-on-a-form-filled-out-decades-ago family with music choices that would really be pushing the envelope -- had not the Church chucked the envelope in the recycle bin years ago, pretty much saying anything goes, if it makes you feel good we'll do it.

If we jettison the prescribed texts, if we forgo any thought that the dead might be in need of prayers.... well, heck, maybe peace DOES begin with me, blessedly assured as I am, as I walk, (Glory, hallelujah!) in the garden.

We really have no standards, so I haven't a leg to stand on in objecting to what are perhaps more unusual but not really more inappropriate songs than our customary fare....

Speaking of prescribed texts, last week one of the priest preached on THE INTROIT.
I would have wept tears of joy, had I not wept tears of chagrin, for he obviously wrote the sermon in the expectation that he would be entering to some Advent hymn, so despite the fact that we actually had sung the entrance antiphon, (in English,) he kept referring to the sentiments that would have been expressed had we not sung a hymn....

I would have concerns about our diction, if this were not the same reverend Father who is wont to carry on loud conversations with departing worshipers over the final verse of a hymn or during a choral postlude; and when it is pointed out that perhaps his microphone just might have accidentally been left on, he cavalierly smiles and sweeps any implicit reproach aside, I don't doubt it! and continues his amplified bandinage.

It's all good....

Sunday, 29 November 2009

If only women, or married men were admitted to the priesthood..."

[The clergy shortage is] not related to money but to vocations. “The bigger pressure is the really quite encouraging number of ordinations is not as big as the number of those retiring.”

Gee, if only those short-sighted fools in charge would see that if they would just permit....

What?

Oh.... never mind.
The Church of England is facing the loss of as many as one in ten paid clergy in the next five years and internal documents seen by The Times admit that the traditional model of a vicar in every parish is over.

The credit crunch and a pension funding crisis have left dioceses facing massive restructuring programmes. Church statistics show that between 2000 and 2013 stipendiary or paid clergy numbers will have fallen by nearly a quarter.

According to figures on the Church of England website, there will be an 8.3 per cent decrease in paid clergy in the next four years, from 8,400 this year to 7,700 in to 2013. This represents a 22.5 per cent decrease since 2000.

"Latin Mass Appeal "

Apparently it was 40 years ago today that all hell broke loose, and its forces, Hell's that is, have been been singing, designing, and filling spot on liturgy committees ever since (actually, I'm not certain the First Sunday of Advent fell on the same date that year, but let it go...)

I kid. (As one of those singers, designers and spot-fillers, I hasten to assure you, I don't really think we're in the employ of the prince of darkness.)

The New York Time has an op-ed piece about the liturgical revolution of four decades ago!
The to-be-expected, (though not in the pages of the Times,) digs at the late Abp. Bugnini.

Many of Bugnini’s reforms were aimed at appeasing non-Catholics, and changes emulating Protestant services were made, including placing altars to face the people instead of a sacrifice toward the liturgical east. As he put it, “We must strip from our ... Catholic liturgy everything which can be the shadow of a stumbling block for our separated brethren, that is, for the Protestants.” (Paradoxically, the Anglicans who will join the Catholic Church as a result of the current pope’s outreach will use a liturgy that often features the priest facing in the same direction as the congregation.)

How was Bugnini able to make such sweeping changes? In part because none of the popes he served were liturgists. Bugnini changed so many things that John’s successor, Paul VI, sometimes did not know the latest directives. The pope once questioned the vestments set out for him by his staff, saying they were the wrong color, only to be told he had eliminated the week-long celebration of Pentecost and could not wear the corresponding red garments for Mass. The pope’s master of ceremonies then witnessed Paul VI break down in tears.

I am curious about this -- I have read this story many times, but never from a primary source, never with attribution.

Is it like the beehive-coiffed woman whose brain was eaten by spiders?

Or the choking doberman?

I don't recognize the name, Kenneth Wolfe.
Should I?

Saturday, 28 November 2009

"Everything I need to know about men..."

This conversation with her six year old son is from the Crescat:
The Crescat: Do you still play with Joey at school?
[back story: Joey was a little boy that lived next door and was The Boy's best friend but his family moved 3 weeks ago.]

The Boy: Not much. We have recess at different times.

The Crescat: Do you miss him?

The Boy: I suppose.

The Crescat: How does Joey like his new house?

The Boy: I don't know.

The Crescat: Has he made any new friends in his new neighborhood?

The Boy: I don't know.

The Crescat: You don't know? You guys still talk right?

The Boy: Yeah! But boys don't talk about junk like that! Geesh!!! [insert huge eye roll]

The Crescat: Really? What do boys talk about then?

The Boy: I don't know mom, good grief! We talk about Storm Troopers and farts and stuff!

"Well known as a good person, he says he has never let his morality interfere with his policy decisions"

Can you imagine a politician making such statement?

Or, "Well, yeah, I hold a code of ethics and behavior, but I would never let my sense of right and wrong affect doing what people want me to do"?

It should be easy, for it happens, for all practical purposes, all the time. (The link is Australian, but it could just as easily be a story about a US pol.)

It is understandable that outsiders might think your Faith is merely a set of rituals and forms, something you take off like fancy-dress clothes to put on your workman's overalls in the real world -- but for for you as a believer to do so is inexcusable.

Yeah, I'm Catholic, but it's not like I believe any of it, or anything...

Friday, 27 November 2009

Cranberries

May I just say that Himself's sister-in-law makes the greatest, most delicious cranberry relish of all time? (Not to mention roasting a pretty mean turkey...)

Thursday, 26 November 2009

"It is not about us, or our ideas..."

I had heard that Canada was worse off liturgically than the US, but this sounds as if it's heading more or less in the right direction. (Perhaps soon they will also be facing in it...)
Liturgy is not meant to be about personal preferences or individual expressions of faith. Instead, says Father Bill Burke, director of the National Liturgy Office of the Canadian Council of Catholic Bishops, it is about the meaning that is intrinsic and exists within it.

"Eucharist is not about our ideas, or about us, in that sense. It is about meaning, the meaning given to it by a young Jew named Jesus and his offering of himself in love to the Father.

"We are not called to create the meaning for ourselves all over again; we are called to enter into it."

Speaking to more than 300 participants at the Table of Hope Conference sponsored by the Diocese of Calgary's Diocesan Liturgy Commission held in Calgary Nov. 21, Burke said the individualism of our culture encourages people to want to insert personal expressions into the liturgy.

He especially sees that in family requests around planning the funeral liturgy.

There is a place for personal expression, but it is not during the funeral liturgy. It is not a celebration of the deceased's life, but an expression of the hope we as Christians have in the resurrection, he said.

"Through liturgy we are incorporated more fully into the life of the Trinity, which is a deep mystery. A Catholic funeral is celebrating the passing over into that mystery in its fullness. We are entrusting the deceased person to that mystery which reaffirms our own trust in the mystery."

While many people today have been cut off from the ritual treasury of the Church, for many reasons, Burke said they still cling to what was known.

"When tragedy strikes we see those spontaneous shrines created at the site. They always include candles, sometimes crosses, and, if a child is involved, teddy bears. People take what they remember, what comforts them in this individualistic society where they feel cut-off and use them again."

Burke said that we do not invent the meaning of the liturgy, we receive it, and it is protected by the rubrics that give both direction as to how the liturgy is to be celebrated and the parameters within which it is acceptable to celebrate.

Bernadette Gasslein, editor of Celebrate!, a Canadian liturgy magazine, and coordinator of liturgical life at St. Charles Parish in Edmonton, agreed.

"Liturgy is being engaged in the act of the love of Jesus to the Father, where he pours out himself to the Father in love, and in response to the Father's love," Gasslein said.

"We need to get a grip on the notion that what we do at liturgy does not begin with us." ...

Liturgy is structured and the structure and the texts have been received from the Church. It is set and has a purpose and meaning that needs to be entered into, not tampered with or changed.

It has a "given-ness" to it and is oriented towards praise of God and intercession for the world. It is ritually structured with gestures, repetition, engagement of the senses through body movement, for example, kneeling, standing and is replete with symbols....

Liturgical prayer has a shape that is significant and is repetitive and familiar. Gasslein likened changing liturgy to changing the rules each time the team comes out to play the game.

She said you would no longer be able to function as a team if that happened. Personal prayer may or may not have shape, though a prayer like the rosary does have shape. Overall, it is more adventuresome and can be new each time.

Liturgical prayer relies on the familiarity with the beauty, the text and the song and symbols as an agent to draw us into the divine, where we enter into the incarnated sphere of Jesus present with us. It is, by its nature, always communal while personal prayer can occur alone

I don't like the overemphasis on the minor matter of shared posture at all moments, but all in all, good stuff.

Wednesday, 25 November 2009

Another Lapse in Judgement to Answer For on Judgement Day....

(Yes, Mrs. Hetherington, if you are reading this, I know it should be " for which to answer")

As if betrayal of a spouse, dereliction of duty and misappropriation of public funds weren't bad enough, doesn't this rise to the level of high crimes and misdemeanors?
(I think I'll googlificate [accent on the second syllable] the date and see if other horrors occurred on April 30, 2005.)
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgCf9_1eBbJid9iyHAeFZao7T6N-Yfssn-KEWJKWobz6PiJfg-JQaP_5je5GwwaCEGUpzz8TA3Xcg-eX2LOFcZQEgAcOugOOKaCZHuWNHPgI3aONzz0LRbxooB1I_73im9K_joS0gr9SYI/s259/resized+dancefree.jpg
http://media.timesrecordnews.com/media/img/photos/2009/03/02/Sarah_2_2-28_t160.jpghttp://thebsreport.files.wordpress.com/2009/06/sanford-mark.jpg

(H/T to Uncle Di at Off the Record.)

Tuesday, 24 November 2009

So Sad...

It is not uncommon for those in crisis to resist any intervention from those who are trying to save their lives.
Not uncommon at all, but still very sad.
The vast majority of U.S. women religious are not complying with a Vatican request to answer questions in a document of inquiry that is part of a three-year study of the congregations. Leaders of congregations, instead, are leaving questions unanswered or sending in letters or copies of their communities' constitutions.

"There's been almost universal resistance," said one women religious familiar with the responses compiled by the congregation leaders. "We are saying 'enough!' In my 40 years in religious life I have never seen such unanimity."

The deadline for the questionnaires to be filled out and returned to the Vatican-appointed apostolic visitator, superior general of the Apostles of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, Mother Mary Clare Millea, was Nov. 20. On that day, according to an informed source, congregation leaders across the nation sent Millea letters and, in many cases, only partial answers to the questionnaire. Many women, instead of filling out the forms, replied by sending in copies of their Vatican -approved orders' religious constitutions.
I wonder, though, if this "vast majority," the "universality" on which they report is any such thing, or merely a majority of those sisters who are known to the often dissenting and equally-in-need-of-intervention NCR community.

Of course, the ones refusing to participate in a process that may be key to any chance of their own survival are probably the communities most desperately in need of aid.

But it is like salvation -- no one forces you to cooperate in the process.

Some people just will not be helped.

I pray to St Joseph, that the death of these fast-fading communities will be happy and painless.

Best Wishes to You and Thine at the Holidays

At The New Liturgical Movement, initiated by the Bow-tied One's post about the new translations and such, 2nd person, or rather 2nd Person, pronouns are the subject.

I have no problem either way, except for the cacophony of final "r"s when the contemporary possessive is sung, but I do think the choice is often a marker for the care and attitude with which the rest of a given text is crafted.

But not always!

For the conversation reminded me of a P & W song I rehearsed on last night, whihc we must sing at an interfaith Thanksgiving service tomorrow night.

Quite aside from the brain-numbing repetitiveness of the words and the insipid, jingley tune -- for reasons unconnected to rhyme, it scampers happily between use of Thee/Thine and You/Yours when addressing God, all in the space of fewer than 2 dozen words.

HUH?

And this is actual published music, from a major publisher.

Over in the aforementioned combox, one poster said:
'And with your spirit' is better, though, than 'You too.'
How 'bout the Missa Hoosieriana's "right back atcha"?

The Family Feud Approach...

I'm planning pre-Mass Christmas music, and reading about polls as to whether Bishop Tobin or the hapless Rep. Kennedy is "right," and my mind is wandering...

I can understand secular press coverage of the latter matter, but am less certain of the point of their voting (who should be kicked out of the Big Brother House next? seems more appropriate to be answered by that means.)

Ever watch Family Feud?

It is the quintessential modern American game show -- why?

Because the contestant's aim is not to come up with the correct answer to anything, but the most popular answer.

We as a society have fetishized "majority rules," not just in deciding upon courses of action, but in discerning truth.
Whatever most people think must be right, right?

How often in programming music intended to give shape to our corporate worship of the Triune God and to edify and sanctify ourselves, is "people like/want/expect it" given as the reason that trumps all others.

A total stranger struck up a conversation with me once during a theater intermission. He asked if I had seen the biggest show in town, a just-opened, multi-million dollar spectacle.

As it happens, he and I had both been at opening night. "Whadya think of...?" he named the leading man.

"Not much," I began, intending to go into the unsupported high notes of his Amercian Idol-style singing, his wayward intonation in the middle of his range, the self-indulgent histrionics that kept him from connecting with anyone else on stage.

I never got the chance, because he interrupted me, demanding, "Three thousand people gave him a standing ovation, who's right, them or you??!?#?!?"

Such a question presumes there is only possible one answer. ("Survey says....")

I don't make a practice of telling people that they are wrong to like what they like, (though if asked I am ready to give reasons for my dismissal of something.)

And there are some questions that really are just matter of "taste."

I'm trying to remember that as I shudder at the thought of some of the choir favorites -- after all this is extra-liturgical.
So what if I like beets and someone else prefers limas...

(Incidentally, so what if Fr Z or anyone else rallies his troops to sway such polls? they are ultimately meaningless attempts to gauge public passion, no?)

"In Chant, Listening and Singing Become One"

This is essentially an arts review, of "performance" chant that I somehow missed in the New York Times this past Sunday, but in it, Chloe Veltman tells some wonderful truths and interesting speculations about chant -- as a device of contemplation, communion and worship (emphasis supplied throughout):
Chant, the practice of intoning sounds or words rhythmically and repetitively, has been a staple of spiritual systems for millenniums. Owing to the popularity of recordings like the 1993 album “Chant” by the Benedictine monks of Santo Domingo de Silos in Spain, and Enigma’s 1990 crossover hit, “Sadeness (Part I),” ...

But chant exists in many forms — including mantras, hymns, prayers, Shigin (a form of Japanese chanted poetry) and plainsong — and can be found in religions as diverse as Judaism, Eastern Orthodox Christianity and Hinduism.

Perhaps in response to the growing velocity and techno-centricity of daily life, more people have sought out chant. The sounds of “om” and “kyrie” are filling Zen meditation centers, Buddhist retreats, plainsong-infused candlelit church services, and yoga studios around the Bay Area and beyond.

Meanwhile, chant has been on the rise as an artistic pursuit. Vocal ensembles like Anonymous 4, Sequentia and Cappella Romana have garnered critical acclaim for their concerts and recordings. The field is clearly evolving. But is chant as engrossing to hear as it is to sing?

In theory, listening to a chant should be roughly the same as singing it. In practice, however, most of us aren’t relaxed, psychologically present or in tune enough with ourselves to be mindful of this effect, which is, after all, quite subtle. As a result, listening to chant, especially without the aid of a religious framework to guide your engagement, can be frustrating.

This was certainly the case last weekend during the Sabbaticus Rex performance at Old First Presbyterian Church in San Francisco. ...

The group’s anti-melodic, seemingly directionless soundscape drove my guest to the point of distraction. She called the music “primitive” and “annoying.”

... by concentrating on my breath and listening for subtle textural and rhythmic changes, like the quiet roar of a gong or the interjection of a rippling flute motif, I was intermittently able to climb inside the ensemble’s musical meditation....

The next morning, I visited the Seventh Avenue Presbyterian Church across town, where I participated in the Medieval Sarum Chant workshop ...

[It] was surprising in some ways. From an aesthetic standpoint, our attempt to sing “Ave Maris Stella,” an English liturgical chant composed in honor of the Virgin Mary, left much to be desired, even though producing a pitch-perfect performance was not the aim of the day.

We weren’t particularly in tune or in step with one another. And learning the chant by rote (as the monks would have done in medieval times), rather than by reading music, added an entirely new level of complexity.

But as we were singing together, time vanished.
I had no idea what “Solve vincla reis, profer lumen caecis” meant, but the act of chanting these words en masse had the same effect on my mood as eating good, dark chocolate. (By the way, it means “Dissolve these earthly chains, give light to the blind.”)

By relating these contrasting experiences, I don’t wish to imply that chant isn’t worthy of performance. Listening to Anonymous 4 sing “Ave Maris Stella” on its “Four Centuries of Chant” CD (released this year on Harmonia Mundi) or in concert demonstrates just how sublime chant can sound to the listener’s ear when the performers follow the contours of the language, flow through the lines and generally possess what Ms. Hellauer calls a “unity of intent.”

Listening to the great Lebanese vocalist Sister Marie Keyrouz intone Middle Eastern Christian chant or Tina Turner sing a Buddhist chant has a comparable effect.

As the Oakland Nada yoga (yoga of sound) expert Ann Dyer put it in a recent phone interview: “Fundamentally, chanting and listening are not that different in terms of how we respond as organisms. Even when you’re listening to chant, the whole body is responding, experiencing the vibration, and the vocal cords will vibrate in sympathy if relaxed. It’s a very kinesthetic response.”

But inasmuch as any activity in life tends to be more meaningful than experiencing it from the sidelines, chant derives much of its power from active participation.

“There is a difference between listening to someone chant and actually making those same sounds in your own body,” Ana Hernández writes in her 2005 book, “The Sacred Art of Chant.” “There’s a difference in the way the vibrations affect you, depending on whether they come from outside or within you.”....


I have no objection whatever to chant as performance.
I wonder why this is?
I saw a shabby chic-ish design program set in New Orleans once and found myself highly offended by pillows and runners in the "splendid ruins" category, that were constructed from antique liturgical vestments.

HIGHLY offended, to see, tucked into the corner of a divan, a gilt-embroidered IHS for someone to lean an elbow or an arse upon.

Why not a similar reaction to the Lord's or the Blessed Virgin's name being bruited about as part of a commercial, secular event by unbelievers? (Not referring to anyone mentioned in the article, I know nothing of any of them.)

Inconsistent, am I?

Oh well, the hobgoblin of little minds, and all that....